Evidence: approaches and debates
These are the approaches my own thinking draws on and argues with, all of which question diagnosis-first psychiatry. Each has supporters and critics, and I have tried to show both. These are summaries, not verdicts, and not advice about your own care.
Relational psychiatry
What it is. An approach that treats the relationship between person and clinician, and the person's relationships and circumstances, as central to understanding and care. Duncan Double sets out the case in Towards a more relational psychiatry (BJPsych Advances, 2021). Research reviewed by McCabe and Priebe suggests that the quality of the therapeutic relationship is linked to outcomes in severe mental illness: The therapeutic relationship in the treatment of severe mental illness (2004).
The other side. A link between relationship and outcome does not prove cause, and "relational" can be hard to define and measure. Most mainstream psychiatrists would say they already value relationships alongside diagnosis and treatment.
Open Dialogue
What it is. A way of responding to crisis, first developed in Western Lapland, Finland. A team meets the person and their network quickly and together, and works through open conversation rather than decisions made about the person. Early Finnish results were encouraging, but they came from observational studies with no randomised comparison: Seikkula and colleagues (2006).
The trial. The UK ODDESSI trial tested a version of Open Dialogue that includes peer support: Pilling and colleagues, Lancet Psychiatry, 2026. On its main measure, time to relapse, it found no difference from usual care. On secondary measures it found fewer hospital admissions, less re-referral to crisis services, and better self-rated recovery, quality of life and satisfaction. Those secondary results were not adjusted for multiple comparisons, so they are promising but need replication.
The other side. An accompanying comment discusses the difficulties of interpreting the results: Hutton and Howard (2026).
The Power Threat Meaning Framework
What it is. A framework published by the British Psychological Society's Division of Clinical Psychology in 2018 as an alternative to diagnosis-led thinking. Instead of "What is wrong with you?", it asks what has happened to you, how it affected you, what sense you made of it, and what you had to do to survive: BPS overview.
The other side. It has drawn strong support and strong criticism, including about its evidence base and its stance on diagnosis. For one critique, see Alastair Morgan, Power, Threat, Meaning Framework: A Philosophical Critique (Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology, 2023).
Medication and the serotonin debate
What it is. Joanna Moncrieff and David Cohen proposed that psychiatric drugs are better understood by the altered states they produce than as correcting a disease: Rethinking models of psychotropic drug action (2005). Her 2022 umbrella review found no consistent evidence that depression is caused by low serotonin: The serotonin theory of depression.
The other side. Sameer Jauhar and 34 co-authors replied that the review's conclusions were overstated, drawing on other kinds of evidence, including studies that lower serotonin experimentally, brain imaging, and how well the medicines work: A leaky umbrella has little value (2023). These critics still see the serotonin system as involved, so the question remains contested. Moncrieff and colleagues responded: both long discarded and still supported? (2023).
Worth knowing. The review was about the cause of depression, not about whether antidepressants help, and it was misreported in both directions. Never stop or change a medicine without talking to your prescriber.
Psychosis as a continuum
What it is. Jim van Os and colleagues argued, from a large meta-analysis, that psychotic experiences lie on a continuum across the population: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the psychosis continuum. Van Os has also argued for dropping the term "schizophrenia": "Schizophrenia" does not exist (BMJ, 2016).
The other side. Both the continuum model and the case for dropping the term are debated, and many clinicians and patients find the existing diagnosis useful.
Meaning in psychosis
What it is. Rosa Ritunnano and colleagues brought together studies of how people experience their delusions. They found that delusions can carry personal meaning and purpose, not only distress: Subjective experience and meaning of delusions in psychosis (Lancet Psychiatry, 2022).
In 2026 the same group followed young people in early intervention services and found that delusions often grow out of overwhelming bodily feeling, carried into belief through metaphor: Delusion as embodied emotion (Lancet Psychiatry, 2026). I came to this through Ritunnano's posts on LinkedIn, and responding to it led to my own piece on reading distress through the body rather than asking people to rate it, Stop Asking the Kudu to Track Itself (January 2026).
The other side. Meaning does not remove risk. As I have written myself, "a coherent and meaningful narrative may still omit delirium, violence, mania, physiological illness or imminent risk."
Mainstream guidance
To see where these ideas agree with standard care and where they differ, read the national guidance too, for example NICE NG222, Depression in adults: treatment and management.
Last updated: 14 November 2026.